Salafi: Where? Muadh Khan: Where have I said that? Salafi: So what is the answer to this question? Salafi: No only from Qur'aan and Sunnah! Salafi: What do you mean? Salafi: No but it is pretty clear what they mean. Salafi: Yes, I agree. Salafi: Maulana Abdul-Ghafoor writes in Salafi: He is a Deobandi Salafi: But this Maulana is a Deobandi Salafi: OK, I will have to find it.
Muadh Khan: What do these verses of the Qur'aan mean? Salafi: Yes we ascribe these verses upon the Dhahir. Salafi: We don't know and we remain Silent? Salafi: I agree with denial with resemblance with the creation. Salafi: What do you say, personally? I refuse to discuss or debate any further. There is no Plan B! I agree with your way Mulla Muadh but there are two things I would like to say.
First is that you should have done Takfir on this Salafi or at least warn him about kufr. He stated clear kufr and this person is not a Muslim! The other thing is that the Maturidi and Ashari methodology is needed for this topic. When asked about where Allah is we first answer that this is a question about Allah's excistence. The question "Where is Allah" is a question of Tawhid.
Allah can only be the way He Is. There is no other way than Him being without space and body. There was no mention of body and space in your discussion.
These are foundations of Islam. Then you can proceed with explaining Ayats suggesting the opposite. You should consult Mawlana Desai. He is one of the Deobandi scholars who has actual knowledge about Ashari Maturidi Aqidah. How a person can do Takfir so easily I'll never understand. Muadh I hope to see the conversation continue from first post and not let the thread derail due to above post. Yasin wrote :. View original post. Abdullah bin Mubarak.
HSATB wrote :. Alhamdolillah we believe in it and we leave its meaning to Allah swt. But those in whose hearts is perversity follow the part thereof that is allegorical, seeking discord, and searching for its hidden meanings, but no one knows its hidden meanings except Allah.
Meaning one is haq and the other batil, please explain. If all the other saffs in salaah are full and you are joining the salaah i heard that you shouldnt start the saff by yourself, you should grab someone from the other saff or get someone else to start the new saff with you, is this correct? Is it right to give bayan for minutes in front of mayyat delaying janazah? Please could you inform me about the permissibility of calling upon deceased friends of ALLAH for help.
Regardless of Milad Sharif or any other special occasions is it having any hasanat in conducting mawleed? Assalam o alaykum, Salam o alaykum, What is the ruling on those who believe that Holy Prophet knew the Quran even before his birth Qabal wiladat hi arif-i-Quran thay. But He Nabi didn't propagate it until it was revelaved to him through Jibrail?
Ye daroode taj aaya kahase , koi hadith me hai ya phir aaise hi kisi ne banaya hai? Jinat from Jahannam views Q. When I was 20 yrs. Then i was really forgoton this, during this period I have made many times tuaba, but I have not mentioned above which i have did in temple in my tauba becasue i have forgot it, and during this period i have recitid many time Kalima, when i becam 25 yrs i was married, but before my marriage Imam Saheb has recited me five Kalima, Imam-e-mujmal and imam-e-mufassal, then my marriage was done and Khutba was done.
The name of baby Boy views Q. Does good jinn and angels help person? What are our beliefs regarding Isa AS? A brother is asking me question regarding his departure and return views Q. Salafies claim that deobandhis do not consider whole Quran sharif as a speech of Allah the allmighty. What do they mean that? Please expalin.
0コメント